"Tsekung asked about government, and Confucius replied: 'People must have sufficient to eat; there must be a sufficient army; and there must be sufficient confidence of the people in the ruler.' 'If you are forced to give up one of these three objectives, what would you go without first?' asked Tsekung. Confucius said, 'I would go without the army first.' 'And if you were forced to go without one of the two remaining factors, what would you rather go without?' asked Tsekung again. 'I would rather go without sufficient food for the people. There have always been deaths in every generation since men lived, but a nation cannot exist without confidence in its ruler.'"
— From The Wisdom of China and India by Lin Yutang.*
Americans have lately been witnessing threats to our republic, starting with election interference (here, here and here); the US abandonment of Afghanistan; an inflation that has reportedly forced people to choose between "heating and eating" and delay medical care; a 2000-mile-long open border that has allowed into the United States "1.7 gotaways" that we know about, as well as reportedly 10 million others, allegedly doubling the number already here, who serve to swell the census, which currently determines the number of seats allocated in the House of Representatives for ten years, as well as the number of delegates in the electoral college; accommodating Chinese Communist Party (CCP), which has been causing "more than 112,000 deaths from fentanyl" in just a 12-month period, the equivalent of one large plane crash a day; failing to challenge the CCP's spy balloon and discontinue TikTok, which has been called "170 million spy balloons"; attempts to criminalize parents "who protest critical race theory and other school policies," Catholics who attend Latin Mass, and attempts generally to "criminalize dissent"; attempts to criminalize politics and political opponents; fabrications that that Hunter Biden's laptop "had all the classic earmarks of a Russian disinformation operation"; alleged lies about involvement in family business dealings; unequal application of the law; funding both sides of both the Hamas-Israel War and Russia's war on Ukraine; engaging in government censorship (here, here, here and here); flouting and the law (here, here and here), then "proudly admitting it," among other activities.
If some of those policies failed to inspire confidence in the ruler, FBI Director Christopher Ray, testifying before the House Judiciary Committee on December 5, 2023, warned, "I see blinking lights everywhere I turn... the threat level has gone to a whole other level since October 7."
When we think about protecting our republic, we might wish to take into account the supportive words of Confucius.
Lawrence Kadish serves on the Board of Governors of Gatestone Institute.
* The Practical Cogitator or The Thinker's Anthology, selected and edited by Charles P. Curtis Jr. and Ferris Greenslet, Houghton, Mifflin Company, Third Edition, 1983, pp.89-91.
David Taylor