How Hamas Leaders Fool Palestinians

by Bassam Tawil
September 25, 2019 at 5:00 am

https://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/14912/hamas-leaders-corruption

Translations of this item:

Polish

"Frustrated Palestinian youths are committing suicide because of poverty, while the sons of the leaders are holding birthday parties!" — Hussein Qatoush, on Facebook.
The problem... is when your father is a senior terrorist leader who devotes himself to inciting against Israel and Jews and encouraging other young Palestinians to sacrifice their lives in the war against Israel. Hamad, like the rest of the Hamas leaders, would never send his own son to attack soldiers at the border with Israel.
It is time for the Palestinians in the Gaza Strip to revolt against the leaders who are keeping them chained in poverty and sending them to their deaths.
It is also time for the international community to wake up to the fact that it is wealthy Hamas leaders, and not Israel, who are responsible for the humanitarian and economic disaster that is known as the Gaza Strip.

In recent years, reports have surfaced regarding the wealth and luxurious lives of Hamas leaders, such as Ismail Haniyeh (pictured), whose capital is estimated at $4 million. It is time for the international community to wake up to the fact that it is wealthy Hamas leaders, and not Israel, who are responsible for the humanitarian and economic disaster that is known as the Gaza Strip. (Image source: Spencer Platt/Getty Images)

The leaders of Hamas, the Palestinian terror group ruling the Gaza Strip since 2007, seem to have hearts of stone regarding the suffering of the people living under their regime.

These leaders have no problem sending Palestinians to risk their lives near the border with Israel, while they and their families enjoy a comfortable life. More than 250 Palestinians have been killed and thousands injured in clashes with the Israel Defense Forces since the beginning of the Hamas-sponsored weekly protests near the Gaza-Israel border in March 2018.

While the protests are continuing and more Palestinians continue to put their lives at risk at the behest of the Hamas leadership, the terror group's senior officials are busy throwing lavish parties for their family members and upgrading their personal treasuries. It is as if the Hamas leaders were telling their people: Sacrifice yourself for the cause of destroying Israel and killing Jews so that we and our families can continue to live it up.

The latest example of this exploitation of Palestinians in the Gaza Strip surfaced in the form of a video of the birthday celebration of 20-year-old Mohammed, son of senior Hamas official Ghazi Hamad.

Hamad, a former deputy foreign minister in the Hamas government of 2012, currently serves as deputy minister in the Hamas-controlled Ministry for Social Welfare and is personally entrusted with overseeing aid to the most impoverished families in the Gaza Strip. Ironically, the man in charge of caring for the poorest families was caught on camera throwing a lavish birthday party for his son.

The video of the birthday party in the Gaza Strip has gone viral on social media. Many Palestinians expressed outrage over the celebration which, they said, took place at a time when the residents of the Hamas-ruled coastal enclave are facing dire economic conditions and are being killed in clashes with the Israeli security forces as they try to infiltrate the border with Israel and throw rocks, petrol bombs and explosive devices at Israeli soldiers.

"The sons of our leaders are always different from the ordinary people," commented Facebook user Ahmad Hassan.

Another Palestinian, Bashar Bashar, wrote: "This party is at the expense of the victims of the weekly demonstrations [near the border with Israel]."

Hussein Qatoush, yet another Facebook user, wrote: "Frustrated Palestinian youths are committing suicide because of poverty, while the sons of the leaders are holding birthday parties!"

Many other social media users said they were not surprised to see a Hamas leader throwing a big party for his son at a time when young Palestinians are fleeing the Gaza Strip because of soaring unemployment and economic hardship there.

The good news is that a growing number of Palestinians seem to be aware of the corruption of their Hamas leaders and the wide gap between the leadership and the people. The bad news is that Palestinians are still afraid to revolt against the Hamas rulers who have been holding them hostage in the Gaza Strip since the terror group's violent takeover of the area 12 years ago.

Alarmed by the widespread criticism, the Hamas leader rushed to issue an "apology," claiming that his son's friends were the ones who held the birthday party and not him.

"I'm not satisfied with this party and I don't accept it," Hamad said.

"I apologize to everyone for this grave mistake. I live a simple life, like the rest of our people. I fully understand the suffering and harsh conditions of our people, and repeat my apology. I promise that this will never happen again."

The Hamas leader, who also promised to "punish" his son, would never have apologized had the video of his son's birthday bash not been leaked on social media. His apology hardly passes as sincere.

In truth, Hamad and the rest of the Hamas leaders owe an apology to the families of the Palestinians they send to attack Israeli soldiers near the border with Israel.

They owe an apology to the thousands of Palestinians killed in wars with Israel because of the rockets Hamas and other terror groups have been firing at Israeli civilians for the past 12 years.

They owe an apology to the tens of thousands of unemployed Palestinians, some of whom are being forced to flee the Gaza Strip in search of a decent life abroad.

They owe an apology to the hundreds of thousands of Palestinian families living in squalor and misery as a result of Hamas's disastrous policies and actions.

Hamad is very, very far from alone in his appropriation of money intended for indigent Palestinians.

In an attempt to calm down Palestinians concerning this issue, Hamas announced on September 23 that it decided to impose a fine of 5,000 Jordan Dinars (about $7,000) on the son of another Hamas leader.

Anas, the son of senior Hamas official Ismail Radwan, was accused of taking advantage of a Saudi grant to families of Palestinians killed in clashes with Israel to travel to Mecca for the Islamic pilgrimage (hajj). Although the Saudi grant was dedicated only for those families, the son of the Hamas leader was able to add his name to the list of beneficiaries.

Many Palestinians took to social media to express their outrage over the trip to Mecca, seriously embarrassing the Hamas leadership for nepotism and corruption.

After the uproar, Hamas formed a commission of inquiry; it concluded that the son of the Hamas leader had acted in "violation of the norms and procedures" concerning the Saudi grant.

Let us return to Hamad, who claims that he lives a "simple life": this is a laughable lie.

In recent years, various reports have surfaced regarding the wealth and luxurious lives of Hamas leaders.

One report suggested that Musa Abu Marzouk, the No. 2 in Hamas, "is considered one of Hamas's wealthiest billionaires, with a wealth estimated at $2-3 billion."

Another report said that the former leader of Hamas, Khaled Masha'al, is worth $2.6 billion. The next Hamas tycoon is Ismail Haniyeh, whose capital is estimated at $4 million, according to Dr. Moshe Elad, a lecturer in the Middle East Department of the Western Galilee Academic College.

Hamas's rivals in the ruling Fatah faction, headed by Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas, say that while Gaza is one of the poorest places in the world, there are 1,700 millionaires among Hamas members. Professor Ahmed Karima of Al-Azhar University, pointed out that Hamas has long become a movement of millionaires. According to Karima, Hamas can count no fewer than 1,200 millionaires among its members.

Generally speaking, it is heartwarming to see parents celebrating their children's birthdays. Palestinians, of course, are entitled to hold birthday parties and other celebrations. It is better to see Palestinians dancing and singing than stabbing Jews or firing rockets at Israeli cities.

The problem, however, is when your father is a senior terrorist leader who devotes himself to inciting against Israel and Jews and encouraging other young Palestinians to sacrifice their lives in the war against Israel. Hamad, like the rest of the Hamas leaders, would never send his own son to attack soldiers at the border with Israel. As far as these leaders are concerned, the blood of their children is apparently redder than the blood of other Palestinians.

It is time for the Palestinians in the Gaza Strip to revolt against the leaders who are keeping them chained in poverty and sending them to their deaths. The birthday party scandal could serve as a trigger for such a revolt. It is also time for the international community to wake up to the fact that it is wealthy Hamas leaders, and not Israel, who are responsible for the humanitarian and economic disaster that is known as the Gaza Strip.

Bassam Tawil is a Muslim Arab based on the Middle East.

© 2024 Gatestone Institute. All rights reserved. The articles printed here do not necessarily reflect the views of the Editors or of Gatestone Institute. No part of the Gatestone website or any of its contents may be reproduced, copied or modified, without the prior written consent of Gatestone Institute.

Recent Articles by Bassam Tawil

UNRWA Hires Palestinian Terrorists, Glorifies Violence And Terrorism, 2024-11-18
Lebanon: Massive 'Underground Combat Sites', 2024-11-05
The Biased Media: What They Make It Their Business Not to See, 2024-10-31
The Biden-Harris Administration Owes Israel's Netanyahu An Apology, 2024-10-20
The Biden-Harris Administration's Misguided Policy On The Palestinians, 2024-10-16

receive the latest by email: subscribe to the free gatestone institute mailing list.

Comment on this item

6 Reader Comments

Shannon • Nov 5, 2019 at 14:49

Hamas Charter is available to read. MB created it. Holyland trial and conviction 2008 in Texas the largest terrorist funding scandal with Co-Conspirators operating as civil rights groups under false pretense. Available at Secure Freedom under press.
Just reading the recordings of what they were saying is enough for anyone to know that it's a huge scam on the people. When they over took Gaza they purposely destroyed so much that was left for the people to use and make $$$. The world has given hundreds of billions. Those that live in Israel don't have to go through what they put them through.
Thankfully the Truth will be revealed. Now, our campuses need to know the Truth too.

Reply->

Phillip P • Sep 27, 2019 at 12:26

At the Geneva Peace Conference with Arab countries on 21 December 1973, Abba Eban said, "the Palestinians never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity." Still today, that stands true and on point. But back then, the reason may have still eluded everyone. No longer.

We have seen over the decades, and through the initiatives of several U.S. presidents and several Israeli prime ministers how Palestinian leadership have forsaken their Arab constituents time and again, leaving them miserable and pitiful.... if not even more worst off.

But, in the meantime, Palestinian leadership never changed (except getting older). Always the same PLO terrorists, now dressed in expensive watches and tailored English or Italian silk suits, they have ALL become billionaires or mega-millionaires.... as did all of their children.

The formula is simple: Incite the people, maintain the confrontations, reject every peace offer/recommendation while spurring 'armed resistance' (with lies and Nazi-like propaganda)...and the billions roll in from the entire world into one major bank account that is controlled by select Fatah leaders.

BTW... The Hamas leadership figured this out long ago, expelled the PLO from Gaza in a bloody coup, and have adopted the same policies. Needless to say, Hamas leaders have also reaped the same benefits becoming billionaires or mega-millionaires.... as did all of their children.

It's time the donor countries woke up from this scam. Or better yet, it's time the Arabs in the region did something about this scam!

Reply->

Mike Kurtzig • Sep 25, 2019 at 14:14

Where are the hundredss of millions of dollars that Iran has pumped into the Gaza Strip. Why are Hamas leaders living the life of luxury while the inhabitants suffer on a daily basis with the lack of jobs, food, medicine, etc. ? Israel continues to supply food, water, electricity, other necessities while the young are sent to the border to die. What type of leadership is that? They could have jobs in Israel but not as long as rockets continue.

Reply->

Bisley • Sep 25, 2019 at 09:46

Hamas, Fatah, etc. maintain themselves in power in much the same way as most other dominant political forces throughout the world. They control most of the information available to most of their public, and use this power to keep their people ignorant of facts that could undermine their policies and power, and indoctrinated and propagandized to believe in what the leadership claims to be doing.

They control news, education, entertainment, most of what's preached in the mosques, etc., and see to it that the majority of their public hears what they want them to hear, and no more. Many are aware that their leadership is corrupt and tyrannical, but see no alternative. Unless a substantial portion of the population comes to understand that most of what they've been taught and led to believe throughout their lives has been propaganda to control them, and that they're being continually lied to from every direction, there isn't much chance of them turning against the leadership that claims to be fighting Israel to restore all of Palestine to them. If they were to come to the point of revolt, they aren't equipped to contest an armed force willing to kill as many as necessary to retain power. Revolt isn't impossible, but unlikely without some drastic change of circumstances.

Reply->

terry m staub • Sep 25, 2019 at 07:37

I find the parallel between how the Hamas hierarchy works and Party membership in a totalitarian socialist society, which is to say most if not all socialist states that declare themselves such. Operating under the pretense that ideology trumps moral and other social accountability because the ends, a perfect Islamic state or socialist dream world is justification. To understand the dynamic further they must have an "enemy" there must be an incarnate boogeyman to justify the sacrifices the masses must make and all of it only to justify the outrageous disparity between the masses and the rule of the imams or commissars, even the "professional" classes are stifled and robbed.

Reply->

David

terry m staub • Sep 26, 2019 at 19:04

Agreed.
Consider the following quotation from Vaclev Havel, former leader of Czechoslovakia:

"Because he regime is captive to its own lies it must falsify everything. It falsifies the past. It falsifies the present and it falsifies the future.It falsifies statistics. It pretends not to posses an omnipotent and unprincipled police apparatus. It pretends to respect human rights, it pretends to prosecute no one. It pretends to fear nothing. It pretends to pretend nothing."

Reply->